Archived Science Blog page from 1999. It stays on Science Blog so the original link still works. It is not a current article. Back to Science Blog

Science Blog -- NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS DECRY TORTURE, DISAPPEARANCES, RELIGIOUS INTOLERANCE, PROBLEMS WITH ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE

Commission on Human Rights Continues Review of Civil and Political Rights

GENEVA, 9 April (UN Information Service) -- An extensive series of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) raised allegations before the Commission on Human Rights this evening of torture, disappearances, instances of religious intolerance, and abuses of judicial standards in a number of countries and regions.

The evening session was used to continue debate under the Commission's agenda item on civil and political rights. Other topics falling under this item are freedom of expression, states of emergency, and conscientious objection to military service.

Among NGOs addressing the gathering was Amnesty International, which charged that torture and extrajudicial killings, arbitrary arrests and secret detentions had become routine in Algeria and that Turkey continued to have widespread problems with torture and disappearances.

The Al-Khoei Foundation expressed concern over the rise of religious intolerance in many parts of the world, particularly as an instrument of Governmental policy, and called attention to cases in Kosovo, Afghanistan and Iraq.

The Arab Organization for Human Rights and North-South XXI condemned detention of Lebanese "hostages" without trial or sentencing in Israeli camps and prisons, while the International Association for Defence of Religious Liberty said there were unsettling situations of religious intolerance in France and Belgium.

Numerous NGOs said the Commission and international community needed to do more to combat impunity -- that serious human rights violations would continue as long as perpetrators were sure they would not be punished.

Representatives of the following NGOs provided formal statements: War Resisters International; World Federation of United Nations Associations; Asian Buddhist Conference for Peace; Al-Khoei Foundation; Amnesty International; General Conference of the Seventh-Day Adventists; International Federation of Journalists; Asian Legal Resource Centre; North-South XXI; Friends World Committee for Consultation; International Association for the Defence of Religious Liberty; Arab Organization for Human Rights; International Association of Democratic Lawyers; Article XIX; Society for Threatened Peoples; International Peace Bureau; International League for the Rights and Liberation of Peoples; African Commission of Health and Human Rights Promoters; Interfaith International; International Association against Torture (also on behalf of December 12 Movement Secretariat); World Council of Churches (on behalf of three other NGOs); Afro-Asian People's Solidarity Organization; Rural Reconstruction Nepal; International League for Human Rights; African Association of Education for Development; Socialist International Women; International Save the Children Alliance; International Federation of ACAT; International Islamic Federation of Student Organizations; Muslim World League; World Muslim Congress; Himalayan Research and Cultural Foundation; World Christian Life Community; International Human Rights Law Group; and World Federation of Trade Unions.

The Commission will reconvene at 10 a.m. Monday, 12 April, to continue its debate on civil and political rights.

MICHEL MONOD, of War Resisters International, said conscientious objection to military service should be supported by the Commission; the Commission should pay special attention to the matter when it was studying reports submitted by member States and by Special Rapporteurs. Military service was often compulsory, and supposedly the reasons for military service were good ones, but in practice it didn't work out that way. Wars were often civil wars; it was difficult for some people to accept that armies existed to protect them.

When towns in regions such as Bosnia or Kosovo were bombed or assaulted by troops of their own supposed countries, what could you say? All were shocked by what was now happening in former Yugoslavia. Should more violence be used to intervene? It seemed only to be further poisoning the situation. Countries should provide for freedom of conscience for those who refused to kill; the Commission should investigate the treatment of conscientious objectors in all armies around the world.

HORACE PERERA, of World Federation of United Nations Associations, said Saudi Arabia violated religious freedom; non-Muslims supposedly had the right to practice their religions there, but they were not allowed to establish and maintain places of worship. Meanwhile Saudi Arabia sponsored the construction

of mosques abroad; why did it not tell Muslims elsewhere to practice their religion in their homes, as it expected people of other faiths to do in Saudi Arabia?

There were many Governments that denied the right to religious education, including the right of children to such education. In other cases there was violence against Christian communities, even in democracies -- India was an example. The Hindu extremism that spawned this violence did not represent the true India. The Federation fully supported the relevant Special Rapporteur's contention that humiliation of and intolerance against women "supposedly prescribed by religion or tradition must resolutely be condemned".

JOSE ANTONIO BELO, of Asian Buddhist Conference for Peace, said he himself was a victim of the Indonesian regime in East Timor; he hoped that his testimony would result in the reduction of torture and killing of individuals by the Indonesian military.

Fellow East Timorese continued to be subjected to horrendous abuses, including electric shocks and beatings. He had grave concerns regarding the repressive military rule that existed in Indonesia and the lack of any legal intercession against the severe violations there to people's right to life. Similarly, he felt concern over the situation in Tibet and the lack of positive response by the Chinese Government to the request of the Dalai Lama for peace for the Tibetan people.

ZAHEER KAZMI, of Al-Khoei Foundation, expressed concern over the rise of religious intolerance in many parts of the world, particularly as an instrument of government policy. Attention was drawn specifically to the cases of Kosovo, Afghanistan and Iraq.

If Europeans were to believe that they were living in a truly tolerant and pluralist society, they should address this issue in the context of relations between indigenous religious groups and with regard to the significant migrant religious communities now residing in Europe, many of which were Muslim. The misuse of religion to attempt to legitimize persecution, for example in Afghanistan, was deplored, and this included prohibitions of the right to health care, education and freedom of movement.

FIONA McELREE, of Amnesty International, said that in Algeria persistent human-rights violations by security forces and abuses by armed groups continued; torture and extrajudicial killings, arbitrary arrests and secret detention had become routine; more than 3,000 people had "disappeared" and their families faced a Governmental wall of silence. The Commission must call on the Government to fully implement the recommendations made by the Human Rights Committee last July, appoint a Special Rapporteur for Algeria, urge the Government to invite relevant thematic Special Rapporteurs to visit, and invite the Working Group on Enforced and Involuntary Disappearances to visit.

Turkey also continued to have widespread problems with torture and disappearances. And Governments in general should act to ensure that lawyers were able to carry out their work without fear of intimidation or reprisal and should provide protection whenever lawyers were threatened.

JOHN GRAZ, of General Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists, said the use of ambiguous words by Governments and the media provoked or justified intolerance. The rise of intolerance in certain democratic countries was of grave concern.

Progress had been made in certain countries in the field of religious freedom, especially in South America and Europe. A dialogue between religious representatives and Governments was the only way to protect freedom, justice and peace.

CAILIN MACKENZIE, of International Federation of Journalists, (IFJ) said the Federation was concerned with the atmosphere of repression within the media community caused by a range of laws used against the media.

Serbia was an example, where enactment of a new information law had created a crackdown on media, especially in Kosovo. There were similar situations in Burkina Faso, Cuba, Paraguay, Peru, Togo, Zambia and Zimbabwe. All amounted to serious constraints on the freedom of the press; related offences often were torture and detention. Action by the Commission could ensure that torture victims, human rights activists, trade unionists, journalists and others could enjoy their human rights.

SANJEEWA LIYANAGE, of Asian Legal Resource Centre, said that the experience of the last few decades in dealing with disappearances clearly showed a serious lack of understanding of the magnitude of the problem, the overall effect of such disappearances on society, the root causes of such occurrences and the fundamental issues that needed to be faced in assisting countries to overcome the aftermath and to prevent similar problems in the future.

The efforts of the international community were insufficient. There had been attempts to deal with the systematic practice of disappearances as a crime against humanity, but the judicial processing of such cases had been very complicated. It was necessary to lay down criteria and guidelines for dealing with such situations, and to end the practice of treating such problems as isolated incidents.

SOUHA BECHARA, of North South XXI, said she had seen detainees of Israeli camps and in 1988 was a prisoner herself and released. Lebanese citizens were being subjected to torture such as electric shock in these camps, and many had died under torture. Mothers had not seen their children for months or years. Age also was no protection against these abuses: a

13-year-old had been detained for six months, and the elderly had been detained as well. A number of individuals were identified as having been detained without charges.

Many detainees were held despite serious illnesses. The Committee should pay attention to the cases of these illegal detainees and support the legitimate demand for their release.

JENNY PICKRELL, of Friends World Committee for Consultation, said that the principled stance of those refusing to take up arms had been recognized by the United Nations as a legitimate expression of the right to freedom of thought, speech and religion. Prohibitions of such pacifist behaviour were wrong, and the right to conscientious objection had been recognized, but not by a sufficient number of States.