Archived Science Blog page from 2008. It stays on Science Blog so the original link still works. It is not a current article. Back to Science Blog

Tofu linked to poorer memory

Reduced brain volume may predict dementia in healthy elderly people

Depression and Chronic Pain resulted in trying Cymbalta for me

Discovery of gigantic, prehistoric platypus - ohannonornithorhynchus gianatinus

Nature Magazine endorses Obama (but not because of science policy)

You can't request more than 20 challenges without solving them. Your previous challenges were flushed.

Loughborough and Oxford scientists, funded by the Alzheimer’s Research Trust, worked with Indonesian colleagues to investigate the effects of high soy consumption in 719 elderly Indonesians living in urban and rural regions of Java.

The researchers’ findings, to be published in Dementias and Geriatric Cognitive Disorders later this month, include evidence that a high consumption of tofu is associated with worsening memory, particularly among the over 68s.

Lead researcher, Professor Eef Hogervorst of Loughborough University, said, “Soy consumption is on the increase in the West and is often promoted as a ‘superfood’. Soy products are rich in micronutrients called phytoestrogens, but it is not entirely clear what their effect on the ageing brain is.

“They have similar effects to oestrogen which may offer neuroprotection to the middle-aged and young but not to over 65s for whom it could heighten risk of dementia and lower memory function.”

Intriguingly, the researchers also found that consuming tempe, a fermented soy product made from whole soy bean, is associated with better memory.

Prof Hogervorst said the beneficial effect of tempe might be related to its high levels of folate, which is known to reduce dementia risk.

“It may be that that the interaction between high levels of both folate and phytoestrogens protects against cognitive impairment.”

Prof Hogervorst said future studies would investigate how folate or folic acid combined with phytoestrogens protects against memory dysfunction in the elderly.

Prof Hogervorst cautioned that the effects of tempe and tofu were most apparent in elderly Javanese people, so it is not clear how the findings relate to soy intake among all ethnic groups. An earlier study found that older Japanese American men were also at increased risk of dementia with high tofu consumption.

Dr Philip Kreager, Senior Research Fellow at the Oxford Institute of Ageing, said, “More generally, consumption of soy products continues to be an important issue for poorer populations in Southeast Asia and elsewhere in the developing world, as soy provides a major alternative protein source to meat.”

Rebecca Wood, Chief Executive of the Alzheimer’s Research Trust said, “This study adds to our understanding of Alzheimer’s disease. Further research is needed to understand the full potential, and risks, of these ‘superfoods’.

“This kind of research into the causes of Alzheimer’s could lead scientists to new ways of preventing this devastating disease. As over half a million people have Alzheimer’s in the today, there is a desperate need to find a new prevention or cure.”

Honestly, the article is not meant for non-vegetarians to jump up and down acting like fools and exclaiming wildly that their meat-eating ways are truly superior. Meat has its drawbacks and can negatively affect mental and physical health, and tofu does as well. They both have their health benefits and for people who don't want to eat meat for issues dealing with animals, tofu also provides some moral benefits.

Do research. Look up studies. Don't just say one way is better based off of a single article that appears in popular science sources. Be well informed.

I for one use tofu and will not stop eating it. I can prepare it and therefore like it. This article cautions me to pay attention to my consumption of tofu as I age and to avoid feeding my children (who I've never planned to put on a vegetarian diet) tofu until they reach a reasonable age.

Be reasonable and pay attention to scientific facts rather than being an extremist.

What they're saying is that it MIGHT be about how tofu is processed in certain areas, it MIGHT be down to how the processing of soy interacts with OTHER parts of the diet (such as folate intake).

"She was having all nataraul banana and some tofu cream or at least that is what she called it. she said her vegetarian ways were better than my sausage eggs and half gallon of syrup o yeah and a sde of bacon.

I guess ill have to forward her this and see if she can remember that delicous breakfast we had"

You're probably eating more soy than the average whole foods vegetarian - it's one of the most ubiquitous foods in the US, particularly in meat and dairy based processed foods.

This is what my aunt told me when i was having a stack of pancakes from a continental breakfast while we were staying at a hotel for my cousins wedding.

She was having all nataraul banana and some tofu cream or at least that is what she called it. she said her vegetarian ways were better than my sausage eggs and half gallon of syrup o yeah and a sde of bacon.

I guess ill have to forward her this and see if she can remember that delicous breakfast we had

Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <sub> <sup> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote>