Archived Science Blog page from 2010. It stays on Science Blog so the original link still works. It is not a current article. Back to Science Blog
It's Okay to Keep Those Feelings Inside
Contrary to popular notions about what is normal or healthy, new research has found that it is okay not to express one's thoughts and feelings after experiencing a collective trauma, such as a school shooting or terrorist attack.
In fact, people who choose not to express their feelings after such an event may be better off than those who do talk about their feelings, according to University at Buffalo psychologist Mark Seery, Ph.D., lead author of a study to appear in the June issue of Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.
The study investigated the mental and physical effects of collective traumas on people who are exposed to a tragedy but who do not experience a direct loss of a friend or family member. It focused on people's responses to the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, but the results may generalize to include responses to other collective traumas.
The findings have important implications for expectations of how people should respond in the face of a collective trauma affecting a whole community or even an entire nation, says Seery, an assistant professor of psychology..
Seery says the results should not be interpreted to mean that expressing one's thoughts and feelings is harmful or that if someone wants to express their emotions they should not do so. "It's important to remember that not everyone copes with events in the same way, and in the immediate aftermath of a collective trauma, it is perfectly healthy to not want to express one's thoughts and feelings," he says.
Seery points out that immediately after last year's tragic shootings at Virginia Tech University there were many "talking head" psychiatrists in the media describing how important it is to get all the students expressing their feelings.
"This perfectly exemplifies the assumption in popular culture, and even in clinical practice, that people need to talk in order to overcome a collective trauma," Seery says.
"Instead, we should be telling people there is likely nothing wrong if they do not want to express their thoughts and feelings after experiencing a collective trauma. In fact, they can cope quite successfully and, according to our results, are likely to be better off than someone who does want to express his or her feelings."
Using a large national sample, Seery and co-researchers tested people's responses to the terrorist attacks of 9/11, beginning immediately after the event and continuing for the following two years. In an online survey, respondents were given the chance to express their thoughts and feelings on the day of 9/11 and a few days afterward.
The researchers then compared people who chose to express their thoughts and feelings versus those who chose not to express.
If the assumption about the necessity of expression is correct -- that failing to express one's feelings indicates some harmful repression or other pathology -- then people who chose not to express should have been more likely to experience negative mental and physical health symptoms over time, the researchers point out.
"However, we found exactly the opposite: people who chose not to express were better off than people who did choose to express," Seery says.
Moreover, when the researchers looked only at people who chose to express their thoughts and feelings, and tested the length of their responses, they found a similar pattern. People who expressed more were worse off than people who expressed less.
"We assessed various alternative explanations in secondary analyses, but nothing else accounts for this effect," Seery says.
Seery's co-researchers were Roxane Cohen Silver, Ph.D., professor of psychology and social behavior, and E. Alison Holman, Ph.D., assistant professor of nursing science, University of California, Irvine; and Whitney A. Ence and Thai Q. Chu, doctoral students, University of California, Santa Barbara.
The University at Buffalo is a premier research-intensive public university, a flagship institution in the State University of New York system that is its largest and most comprehensive campus. UB's more than 28,000 students pursue their academic interests through more than 300 undergraduate, graduate and professional degree programs. Founded in 1846, the University at Buffalo is a member of the Association of American Universities.
Some good points have been made already. I think it is also important to ask this...Should we be comparing the outcomes experienced by those who chose to talk to those who did not, or should we be comparing their outcomes to what they might have experienced had they not talked. I think the important thing is the latter especially given that we know everyone's experience of trauma is unique.
"The study investigated the mental and physical effects of collective traumas on people who are exposed to a tragedy but who do not experience a direct loss of a friend or family member."
So something bad happened and some people died, but everyone who 'matters' to the folks being studied weren't involved?
Call me callous or apathetic but at a certain point, you don't worry about people you don't know.
I am sick and tired of either victimizing, or making ok everything, every time a psychologist does some "research". People are much harder than most "research" would make you believe, and they are quite different from one another. We shouldn't victimize and say what is "the right thing" to do. Let everyone express the stress as s/he wants. Family and friends should only discreetly watch for signs of extreme behaviour (eg suicidal,etc).
Okay, this was obvious to me... People these researchers followed that supposedly "expressed" their feelings clearly expressed them to the *researchers*. These people are more likely to have little social support for them to express their feelings to the researchers instead of someone whom they intimately trust.
Thus, those less likely to express probably have better social support (and in actuality, do express themselves... but to people that actually, well, matter, instead of people feeding on them for research).
This article cover,911 politico cultural economic issue oil, again into this magic word terrorist attacks of 9/11,,,all big term mix as a good soup{such as a school shooting or terrorist attack.}I will believe mixing terrorist and school shooting ,,will get any Clinical Psychology research-intensive whatever unrealistic,and definitely ,base on the age of a teenager with good family background,good mark ,,maybe good actor who nose the link to an Islamic inextremist at the same age ,with good faith and enjoying coca kola,and love Hollywood movie.......the Key of the why they did that killing.it is a pop can ,,,,brain please sure it will applied but after covering the earth the department will bankruptcy,,,and human kind will star trek the universe.
Does the study provide any reason not to suppose that people with worse problems are talking more because they're more strongly affected, rather than the other way around? In other words, is there any reason to favor either of these explanations:
A) [what the article implies] After a traumatic event, people who talk about it more are likely to have more problems.
B) After a traumatic event, people who have more problems are more likely to talk about it more.
DUH! Expressing your feelings to improve mental health was borne of a limited view of human psychology. Since then we have learned much, collectively.
Lets see, CEOs and salespeople tend to be sociopathic. That is now being viewed as one version of normal.
On other horizons we are finding that normal is not a narrow range of being, but a wide range of possibilities. So there is no correct version of healthy that is narrow in scope or definition. To believe that there is is simple hubris.