Hurricane Dean's Global Warning (note spelling, n not m)?

Hurricane Dean is now officially among the top ten strongest Atlantic storms ever measured. Even more telling, six of the top ten have occurred during the past ten years.
True, our measurement techniques have improved, but even taking that into account, the fact is remarkable.
This may be a statistical fluke. It's too soon to say, but it bears watching. At the very least, we need to plan for the possibility that the more severe global warming scenarios are coming to pass.
To quote a blog posting by science journalist Chris Mooney:
...even though Dean was not “caused” by global warming, when considered in its Atlantic context the storm is certainly consistent with the argument that there’s something going on out there that’s new–and more than a little scary.
Mooney is exceptionally well informed on this issue, and he has been cautious in his language about possible linkages between global warming and hurricanes. It only makes sense that rising ocean surface temperatures will change hurricanes in some way, but that is only one factor in a complex climate system. It's difficult to predict what changes will occur in hurricane strength, frequency, and distribution.
He discusses this in some detail in his new book, Storm World: Hurricanes, Politics, and the Battle Over Global Warming.
So if we want to get a handle on what changes are occurring, we need to both watch the data and refine our storm models. The data--admittedly very limited--is not very reassuring so far.
I know I'll be accused of being alarmist by some readers, but I am not advocating panic mode or extreme responses. I am calling for judicious urgency. People and governments may need to respond more vigorously to global warming than they have been. If so, we need to be prepared.


iUmTGIjHEDhJIo
ivaedocvunf@gmail.com
It's difficult to predict
It's difficult to predict what changes will occur in hurricane strength, frequency, and distribution.
Please delete "It's difficult to predict" and then delete this
The link it includes points to a porn site.
At the very least, that makes it a time waster, but I'd call it SPAM
Fred Bortz -- Science and technology books for young readers (www.fredbortz.com) and Science book reviews (www.scienceshelf.com)
re: "fallacy of correlation implies causation"
Fred goes to some effort (more than most) to make it clear that it's too soon to tell, and that climate is a complex system, so I don't think there's danger in this post being seen as an island of correlation pointing to causation.
Correct me if I'm wrong (and I'm sure Fred will) but many respected models of the effects of climate change predict stronger hurricanes (and more extreme weather in general). So, that there is a correlation here that points to causation I think can be entertained. If there were no models that predicted this, if this were just some correlation pulled form the air, then I think a warning would be warranted.
In this case I would caution against not correlating these results with causation. A logical fallacy only means "conclusion is not true in one or more cases", but does not rule out the cases in which "conclusion = true". In the case of climate change (or any complex system) it's necessary to predict and react based on incomplete understanding of the future. I differ with Fred on what course of action is available to us, but that's a different argument.
qEdLeXpUbFl
ivaedocvunf@gmail.com
Necessary arguments
Brendan wrote, among a number of other useful statements:
In the case of climate change (or any complex system) it's necessary to predict and react based on incomplete understanding of the future. I differ with Fred on what course of action is available to us, but that's a different argument.
Yes, that is a different argument, and one that is essential to have. When I used the words "judicious urgency," I wasn't talking about any particular set of actions. I was talking about having the necessary political discussions so we will be better prepared to act quickly if necessary.
See, for example, what I write about Newt Gingrich and Terry Maple's upcoming book, A Contract With The Earth.
As for the very interesting science behind the relationship between global warming and changes in hurricanes, I recommend Chris Mooney's well-researched and exceptionally readable narrative, Storm World: Hurricanes, Politics, and the Battle Over Global Warming.
Fred Bortz -- Science and technology books for young readers (www.fredbortz.com) and Science book reviews (www.scienceshelf.com)
Sensationalizing the limited empirical data
Yes, there is a trend towards stronger hurricanes. The data indicates this rather plainly.
Just don't fall into the logical fallacy of correlation implies causation.