Archived Science Blog page from 2009. It stays on Science Blog so the original link still works. It is not a current article. Back to Science Blog
Has the climate change debate reached a tipping point?
In recent months, mainstream scientists have been more willing to speak out about speculation that global warming may mean that Earth's climate is on the verge of a possibly catastrophic "tipping point," beyond which future human technology will not be able to undo the effects of past and ongoing excesses. People who view this as a left-wing ideological issue may have to change their tone, now that
a group of prominent evangelical Christians have called for environmental action before it is too late.
, Sagan spoke of the need for science and religion to come together as stewards of planet Earth. He debunked the idea that the debate of climate change is a partisan issue.
Over the next few months, I will be reviewing at least two new books on climate change to supplement
We should also consider the recent past: 1000 AD was much warmer than now.
The best book I've seen that puts the medieval warm period and the "Little Ice Age" in perspective, both scientifically and socio-politically, is "The Little Ice Age: How Climate Changed History" by Brian Fagan, reviewed at
As for the various issues raised by your link, the recent IPCC deliberations considered all of them and concluded that to a high level of probability, human activities, primarily the burning of fossil fuels, are the cause of the present warming episode.
) discuss solar effects, including other than total insolation, on both Mars and Neptune.
I also have a long discussion about persuading my conservative friend that global warming is not part of a liberal political agenda.
As you will discover when reading those entries, I have a healthy appreciation for the views of skeptics, but I also have a healthy appreciation for the process that has led to the current scientific consensus.
Politicians need to argue about what to do about global warming, but they need to start from a common scientific base. Too many of them are still busy attacking the scientists as either conspirators or dupes, because the science seems to be leading toward actions that will minimize the economic and political power of their political supporters, Big Oil and Big Coal.
No matter what political strategy emerges, the scientific consensus tells us that we need to burn much less fossil fuel if we want to solve this problem. No wonder the fossil fuel interests attack both the scientists and their consensus.
In any case, I invite your comments on my more recent blog entries.
Now you're starting to sound ideological. You are misinterpreting scientists' inherent caution not to overstate their conclusions as talking "like lawyers."
All data have inherent uncertainties and no one can be absolutely certain about their conclusions. However, there is a scientific consensus that represents the best understanding we have at this time. The consensus is growing stronger as the data, models, and computing power get better.
The implications of the consensus are raising serious concerns. We can't wait for a "smoking gun" before we act, because it will be too late at that point.
I am not an expert, just well-read on the subject. I have directed you to a number of books that can help you to understand the way this scientific consensus has developed. It's now up to you to do the hard work of absorbing the data and understanding the consensus. Neither the scientists at Scripps nor I can do that learning for you.
It's time for you to stop asking questions here and start reading. You need to understand both the process of science and the results. The answers to your questions are in the books I've recommended. How can I possibly describe all the details and the many examples in those books in this blog?
This dialogue has run its course. Please do not reply. Just go read if you really want to understand.
Fred Bortz -- Science and technology books for young readers (www.fredbortz.com) and Science book reviews (www.scienceshelf.com)
"People who view this as a left-wing ideological issue" aren't going to be swayed by a bunch of non-scientists jumping on the bandwagon. The reason we think it's an ideological issue is because we're not convinced by the scientific findings, not because we're "right-wing" (although I am :-) ).
That's an ideological statement, which is why I added the "smiley."
But it is not ideological to respect a scientific consensus that has built up over decades. Some of
the weather and climate books reviewed on my Science Shelf website
have an ideological bent, but most focus on the evidence and the growing scientific consensus.
Nonscientists who know how scientists build consensus now recognize that there may be huge problems ahead. Not acting can have serious consequences.
In the religious realm that plays out this way: Many scientists and nonscientists espouse conservative religious faiths that place the stewardship of the planet as an important aspect of doing "God's work." Others, such as members of my liberal denomination, include "repairing the world" as one of their central good deeds. That repair is social as well as physical. The sentiment is not ideological, even when ideologues happen to hold it.
If you're having problems accepting the scientific consensus, I suggest that you click the link earlier in this reply and select reading material from the titles you think are least ideological.
I'm afraid that you remain unconvinced because you wish things were different from the way they are. It's almost "magical" thinking, and few things are more dangerous than relying on magic instead of acting on fact.
Fred Bortz -- Science and technology books for young readers (