Archived Science Blog page from 2010. It stays on Science Blog so the original link still works. It is not a current article. Back to Science Blog

First second-hand smoke death?

A young asthmatic woman who collapsed and died shortly after arriving for her shift as a waitress at a bar may be the first reported death to be reported nationally from acute asthma associated with environmental tobacco smoke.

physician, published in the February edition of the American Journal of Industrial Medicine, not only outlines circumstances under which the woman died, but also raises a number of issues regarding safety in the workplace.

The report states the woman arrived at the bar in Michigan and, according to co-workers, seemed happy and healthy. About 15 or 20 minutes later she collapsed and within a few minutes died.

"This is the first reported acute asthma death associated with work-related ETS," said Kenneth Rosenman, an MSU professor of medicine and chief of the Division of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. "Recent studies of air quality and asthma among bar and restaurant workers before and after smoking bans support this association."

In 2006, the surgeon general’s report concluded that ETS causes coronary heart disease, lung cancer and premature death. But at that time there was little hard evidence linking ETS to the exacerbation of asthma in adults.

However, Rosenman and colleagues believe this case provides plenty of evidence to link secondhand smoke to this death.

"The autopsy clearly indicates she died from asthma," Rosenman said. "There was no other cause of death. Her death is consistent with what we know about exposures in bars like this. We know asthmatics are more susceptible to irritants and other particulates in the air.

"We know that particulate levels from secondhand cigarette smoke in bars like this reach sufficient levels to set off an asthma attack."

As an occupational and environmental health physician, Rosenman said he also is concerned about the long-term effects of ETS on all employees, not just those with pre-existing conditions like asthma.

"As a consumer, I don’t have to go into that bar," he said. "But is it a safe environment for the employees? We have federal laws that say employers have to provide a safe and healthy workplace. This was clearly not a safe and healthy workplace for this employee.

"This death dramatizes the need to enact legal protections for workers in the hospitality industry from secondhand smoke."

In the United States, 23 states have already banned smoking in restaurants and bars. A number of other states, including Michigan, are considering it.

While many bar and restaurant owners say a smoking ban would hurt business, Rosenman argues that just the opposite is true.

"Consider that 75 percent of the population doesn’t smoke," he said. "Banning smoking could actually serve to increase business. Studies of restaurants and bars in Boston, New York City, San Francisco and Washington D.C. all show business up since they banned smoking. Chicago went smoke free the beginning of this year.

"We’re behind the times if we want to attract tourists and help businesses be more profitable."

Three public health disease-tracking systems in Michigan were used to gather information for this case report.

Other members of the research included Martha Stanbury, Michigan Department of Community Health; and Debra Chester and Elizabeth Hanna of MSU’s Division of Occupational and Environmental Medicine.

The project was funded by grants from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Ya I also heard that ETS causes the inhaler to not wash their hands after they use the restroom, grow vestigial arms, and eat their own poo. For one, if your retarded enough to work in a smokey environment beit a auto shop, ore refinery, or even a bar with asthma,then you shouldnt be allowed to breed. Secondly, note the word "some"-this means it was a guess. "Some 35-48000 americans" its a guess....its not like its actual data. To be taken with a grain of salt because it doesnt mean anything. Thirdly, the American Heart and Lung Association will tell you ANYTHING causes cancer, even breathing the cleanest air. I'm sorry guys, but we have to put the brakes on somewhere, the world we live in is not perfect, and it would suck to live in a antiseptic society of germophobes. Theres other things in your life that arnt as petty as this to waste your time thinking about.

dude the international cancer genome consortium (what a weird name) has just found that for every one cigarette that you smoke, you get about one gene mutation, considering how little genes it takes to start mess up and cause cancer, your basicly playing a large game of russian rullet....if you do the math and add up the amount of cigarettes you will smoke/ have smoked you'll find that number is alarminly high and it just piles on the gene mutations

incidence of SUDDEN DEATH among the asthmatic population has been increasing annually and most likely IS DUE TO their meds.

WHAT did the autopsy reveal and why would an astmatic anything be working with irritants or tobacco smoke wasn't as provoking as perfumes etc ?

And it's amazing how many non-smokers think that they're going to contract lung cancer from ETS. Maybe something like this story will bring them to their senses and show you only need asthma and to forget your inhaler when you leave your home. I certainly hope so anyway.

The free market ensures that there will be exactly as many non-smoking bars as people want. Everyone wins!

If there was such a demand for non-smoking bars, why wasn't there plenty of them to begin with, instead of having to mandate that they all become smoke free?

Because that isn't what the majority of the people who go to bars want, that's why.

In Iowa, the Democrats just imposed a smoking ban on all bars, while leaving the state owned, cash-cow casinos exempt from the ban.

I'm not making this up. They said, with a straight face, that they don't think the smoking ban will hurt the bar business -- while at the same time exempting the casinos from the same law. And so they left themselves WIDE OPEN for a lawsuit which is being filed by the bar owners association, citing the unconstutionality of the smoking ban and the casino exemption.

63,000 people die every year from second hand smoke, really? How do you that? Who told you that? How do you know that is correct? At what age did these people die? Were there other conditions that might have contributed to their death such as asthma, a pre-existing heart condition or a family history of disease related to their death?

How precisely does a whiff of tobacco smoke kill a person? Yes, smoking for 50 years will kill a person, this fact has been correlated beyond reasonable doubt, but how does just a whiff every now and then kill someone, precisely? The correlation between secondhand smoke and death is exceedingly weak, and correlation has never equaled causation, although it can be a damn good indicator when it is overwhelming like the relationship between smoking for many years and developing a health problem. Given that the same chemicals present in tobacco smoke are also produced by other sources including but not limited to burning anything carbon based, and all the same chemicals are present in nearly everything is it really rational to point out cigarettes as the cause?