Reply to comment

The question, "do words have definitions", is the fundamental issue presented in the article. As to whether variations of the generally understood definition of a chair, or the structural variations of the generally understood concept of a chair, satisfy the "standard" definition of a chair is a different question. If definitions are secondary, what is primary? I would argue that definitions; even those with indefinite or confused meanings are primary, in that such words and their definitions are the starting point from which any discussion about said variations can be cognized or explored. It is not clear to me how this subject about chairs, in their various forms, relate to, "do words have definitions". Perhaps I am missing the point. Please explain. I am willing and desirous to learn. Of course, common usage can change and vary the understanding, definition, and meaning of words. Common usage over time "forces" lexicographers to redefine words. I use the word, "forces" because they prefer the standard definitions; as it applies to established literature and usage. Why? Simple, the new definitions render the understanding of past literature difficult or impossible to interpret. I am not suggesting that much of this change is unnecessary or unjustified. Notwithstanding, such changes, in word usage requires a broader understand of past and present word usage. In summary, words and their definitions, determine or demarcate the initial understanding of the words in question, yet common usage can potentially vary their meaning; in "everyday" parlance. Common usage does not actually change their meaning, at least in the short-term. The mere fact that words can be misunderstood, misused or varied does not change their fundamental meaning. Why is this important? If you hire a lawyer, broker, doctor, or any other professional, you better hope that exactness of language is employed. Established and well defined understanding of words and terms are absolutely necessary to articulate your case, or relate information to other professionals, if you expect the best possible outcome. Therefore, we must make a clear distinct between common word usage and definitions, and standard; well established word usage among skilled practitioners, in various professions, we entrust in our defense or care.